Things that bother me in Pushing Daisies1. Chuck is always referred to as a girl, both by Emerson and by the narrator. Emerson might call Ned "Pie Boy," but the narration allows for a more adult "the Piemaker." Imagine their places reversed--can you really see aliveagain!Ned being called "the boy called Ned"?
2. There is indication that Ned has had intimate relationships prior to Chuck, if embarrassing, bearskin-rug filled ones. The only indication of sexuality on Chuck's part, pre-Ned, is reading dirty novels belonging to Lily (?).
3. The implication that a girl should end up with her first kiss is weird and kind of skeezy, especially when her first kiss happens at the age of nine. Does that feel to anyone else like it suggests her development of character is basically complete at that point? Is that not incredibly weird and gross and insulting?
4. Chuck doesn't get to bring any friends into the group. Emerson and Olive belong to Ned, and neither particularly like her at first. Lily and Vivian are occasional walk-ons, but they basically belong to Olive at this point in time. Chuck's father, the only person she gets to choose to have contact with over a multi-episode business? He takes off. Chuck has Ned, but Chuck is
Ned's walk-on, as it were.
5. Crunched because of time, I'm sure--given that the Oscar Verbinius (check spelling when it's not 1:30 DX) storyline was supposed to be 4-5 episodes long, it better have been--but every time Ned and Chuck have some kind of spat, it's essentially resolved by the end of the episode. Chuck never gets to get properly angry at Ned or anyone else. She gets to be tearful and sad-looking, and maybe sometimes there's anger underneath that (the final episodes of the second season go that direction, especially the very last one), but she's sort of missing a properly pissed-off mode and in my opinion, kind of seems like she should have one. And maybe getting angry involves crying for her, and that's fine. I know it does for me a lot. But Chuck seems to slip into sad-quiet-crying; she's unhappy, but she's incredibly
docile about her unhappiness.
6. Chuck is not only basically immortal, she's ageless. Which is a nice plus for Ned, as far as His Perfect Woman goes, I'm sure.
7. The fuck is Chuck's job? She gets to have a share in their little mini-detective agency, okay. She helps out at the Pie Hole. But pies are not primarily Her Thing, and neither is detectiving (even if she gets to use her language skills and etc. on occasion).
Everyone else has a thing they enjoy or enjoyed, and which they do or did for a living at some point. Chuck has hobbies that help other people's Things out. I get it, she has to hide from the world, but this is a universe where she can call herself Kitty Pimms and they don't go "Okay, SSN?" She could have a job, theoretically.
8. Why do we see teenaged!Chuck but never teenaged!Ned? Why do we have Anna Friel rouged up and put in pigtails, but never Lee Pace in a schoolboy's uniform?
And to be honest, on a completely unrelated note, I'd love to know about Ned's teenage years, because they are not basically touched at all, and I bet they were hilaaaaariously awkward. 9. How often does this show pass the Bechdel test? Often enough when Olive talks to Lily and Vivian, I imagine, but whenever Chuck talks to Olive, it almost always comes around to Ned some way or another. And that bugs me. Yes, they're in a triangle and that's awkward, but they both have interests outside of Ned--that much is clear. But the majority of their conversations? Ned. Nednednednedned.
I suspect it all boils down to one question: Don't we ever get
tired of the fresh-faced ingénue? Especially when she's supposed to be nearly thirty? Couldn't we have a girl-next-door who's allowed to grow up some? The series wanted to, I think (hope), and eventually, maybe it would have gotten there. As it is, though, there are things that seriously bother me and that don't seem to be getting addressed anywhere--in fandom, by the creators, by other bloggers.
I want to see these things, and all those that I forgot or never noticed, addressed by other people. Preferably the creators, in interviews and comics and whatever you like, but by fandom, too. I wish I could write it up in a
metafandom-worthy sort of way, but I'm betting I can't motivate myself to, lolfail.